题干

阅读下面的文章,完成下列小题。

你为什么该摆脱“权威偏误”

    如果不服从权威,会发生什么事?《圣经》第一章就说得明明白白:会被逐出天堂。各个领域的权威们——政治家、科学家、医生、首席执行官、经济学家、政府官员、体育评论员、企业顾问和证券大师们——也想让我们相信此事。

    关于权威有两个问题。首先是令人警醒的跟踪记录。这个星球上有大约100万受过培训的经济学家,没有一位精确预言了金融危机发生的时间,更别说房地产泡沫的破裂、信用违约互换的瓦解直到通货膨胀引发的经济危机的顺序了。再没有哪个专家群体失灵得比这更惊人了。

    其次,经常可以证明,权威也会出错。出错是人类的通病,但重要的是,面对权威我们会将独立思考调低一级。面对专家意见时我们往往会比面对其他意见粗心许多。还有,我们会服从权威,哪怕是在理性或道德上毫无意义的地方。这就是权威偏误。

    年轻的心理学家斯坦利·米尔格拉姆1961年做了一个试验,将权威偏误揭示得一览无遗。试验时他请求一位受试者电击坐在玻璃窗另一侧的一个人,并逐渐增加电压。从15伏开始,然后是30伏、45伏,以此类推,直到几乎致命的450伏。即使受折磨的那个人痛得大喊大叫,浑身颤抖(事实上没有电流,那只是一位演员),受试者想中断实验,但只要米尔格拉姆平静地说“请继续,实验要求这样做”,大多数人都会继续做下去。半数以上的受试者将电压升到了最高——纯粹是在服从权威。

    近几十年来,航空公司明白了权威偏误有可能造成危险。许多意外事故之所以发生,都是因为机长犯了错,副机长察觉了错误,但出于相信权威不敢指出来。大约15年以来,几乎所有航空公司的飞行员都接受了所谓的“机组资源管理”训练,学习坦率、迅速指出毛病。 换句话说:他们训练自己努力摆脱权威偏误。

    几十年后,许多公司纷纷向航空公司学习。特别是当有一位强势的首席执行官时,员工患上权威偏误的危险就更大,这对公司很不利。

    专家们希望被人认出,为此他们必须用某种信号显示他们的身份。医生和研究人员是通过他们的白大褂,银行行长则是通过西服和领带。领带没有作用,它只是一种信号。国王们头戴王冠,军队中有军衔标志,基督教会里的权威信号更是明显。其他信号还有名人访谈的邀请、图书和其他出版物等。

    任何时候都有不同的权威“流行”。有时是神职人员,有时是国王、武士、罗马教皇、哲学家、诗人、摇滚明星、电视制作人、互联网公司创始人、对冲基金经理、银行总裁。因此存在权威时,社会总是乐于跟从。如果权威们想跨界得到认真对待,将会引起混乱。比如,当一位职业网球运动员推荐咖啡机或一位女演员推荐治疗扁桃腺炎的药的时候。

    不管什么时候遇到一位专家,我都会设法向他挑战。请你也这么做。你对权威的批判性越强,你就越自由,就越相信自己有更多的能力。

上一题 下一题 0.0难度 选择题 更新时间:2019-11-22 01:10:55

答案(点此获取答案解析)

同类题4

阅读下列短文,从每题所给的 A、B、C 和 D 四个选项中,选出最佳选项。

    I owned my own piano company in my thirties. Once, I received a postcard saying, "Please bring me a new piano for my little granddaughter. It must be red mahogany.  I can pay $10 a month with my egg money." Of course, I could not see a new piano for $10 a month. No finance company would carry a contract (合同) with payments that small.

    For months, I ignored them but the postcards were constantly coming to me. Out of curiosity, I looked the old lady up: She lived in a one-room cabin(小屋)in the middle of a cotton field and her little granddaughter was barefoot and wearing a feed-sack dress.

    Finding a red mahogany piano on my little truck, I delivered it to her and told her I would carry the contract myself at $10 a month with no interest, and that would mean 52 payments. I was sure I had just thrown away a new piano. Incredibly, the payments came in, all 52 of them as agreed.

    Then one day after 20 years, I sat in the Holiday Inn having a drink, I heard the most beautiful piano music behind me. I looked around, and there was a lovely young woman playing a very nice grand piano. I moved to a table beside her. She smiled at me, and when she took a break, she sat down at my table.

    "Aren't you the man who sold my grandma a piano a long time ago?" It didn't ring a bell, so I asked her to explain.

    She started to tell me, and I suddenly remembered. My Lord, it was her, the little barefoot girl in the feed-sack dress!

    She told me her name was Elise and since her grandmother couldn't afford to pay for lessons, she had learned to play by listening to the radio. She said she had started to play in church, then in school, and had won many awards and a music scholarship. She had married an lawyer in Memphis and he had bought her that beautiful grand piano she was playing.

    Something else entered my mind. "Elise," I asked, "It's a little dark in here. What color is that piano?" "It's red mahogany," she said, "Why?"

    I couldn't speak.

    Did she understand the full meaning of the red mahogany? The unbelievable insistence of her grandmother on a red mahogany piano when no one in his right mind would have sold her a piano of any kind? I don't think so.

    But I did, and my throat tightened.