题干

某校九年级开展社会热点评述活动,同学们围绕2018年年初刷爆朋友圈的“高铁扒门”事件展开了热议。

【事件回放】2018年年初,一段视频引发网友关注:罗某为了让丈夫赶上高铁而用身体阻挡高铁车门关闭,经多次劝解仍强行扒阻车门。网民们对罗某行为发出如潮评论,多数人指责罗某的行为。更有网友人肉搜索曝光了罗某的个人信息。之后一条题为“扒车门阻高铁事件再发酵”的信息开始在网络传播。该信息称,罗某的老公是刑警大队长,没有买票,已被公安部免职审查,罗某的行为导致三百趟火车时间重新调整等。经警方调查核实,该信息系谣言。

【议论纷纷】


请综合运用学科观点,任选上述一位同学的说法予以评析。

上一题 下一题 0.0难度 选择题 更新时间:2011-01-21 08:41:38

答案(点此获取答案解析)

选甲:同意甲的观点。罗某的行为属于一般违法行为。个人利益与社会公共利益发生矛盾时应服从社会公共利益;公民应该尊重规则,遵守规则才能更好的维护社会公共秩序;对社会负责的公民应遵纪守法;罗某的行为是不自尊、不自爱的表现。

选乙:不同意乙的观点。网友人肉并公开罗某个人信息是违法行为,侵犯了罗某隐私权。公民在强调自身权益的同时,不能损害他人的、国家的和社会的合法权益。罗某作为公民的人身权利受到法律保护,即使罗某的行为涉嫌违法,但是她的人身权利是受法律保护的。

同类题3

阅读下列短文,从每题所给的A、B、C和D项中,选出最佳选项。

Guilin is my favorite city in China because of its beauty, its waterways, its cafes, and most of all because I met my wife there. It is her hometown and we will both retire there in a few years.

Not only is Guilin a fascinating city, there are many interesting places to visit within a short drive from there. The Ling (sometimes called Lingqu) canal is the oldest canal in the world. It was built about 2,200 years ago and connects two major river systems, the Yangtze (to the east) and the Pearl River.

Longsheng Rice Terraces (龙胜梯田) is another manmade wonder that was built around 650 years ago. I have some photos of both of these places in my China Daily homepage Albums. Gudong Waterfall Park(古东瀑布) is another attraction that is worth visiting. The hike to the top of all these waterfalls isn’t very difficult and if you want, you can take a ride to the bottom on a personal rail car whose speed you can control with a brake.

If you want you can also climb up some of the waterfalls with the help of chains that are placed for the convenience of amateur climbers.

I have only been in Guilin during the winter and spring but my wife tells me it gets pretty hot in the summertime. That’s OK because I grew up in the Midwest of the US where it gets very hot and humid during the summer months. It rarely freezes in the winter and the spring and autumn are pleasant. Guilin receives a lot of rain, especially in late spring and early summer. Because of this there is lush(多汁的) plant life and many large trees in the area. 

Being from California I’m used to having a car to get around. In fact, it’s practically a necessity in California. But in Guilin almost everything is within walking distance and if you need to go further, public buses are available every five minutes on the busy streets and every 10-15 minutes just about everywhere else. There are plenty of taxis too and most trips are only six yuan.

It’s a perfect place to retire.